What frick you say to me you outdated piece of crap toting revolving mistake.
I’ll have you know that I watched Terminator 2 over 9000 times and can easily reload my Henry with one hand on a motorcycle and say get to the chopper while shooting off some predators in the middle of a spaceship with Xenomorphs.
You’re friken dead kiddo.
ROF: Henry has a lead here, by about 20 rpm. (the carbine has a fake RPM even if you dont oversample the firecap)
One shot Potential: Lets face it, the Henry can more reliably One shot people due to how its multipliers work.
Velocity: Sorry western fans, have to give it to the carbine.
Capacity: Normally it would go to carbine but the Henry can top off, so mostly a tie.
CQC:Depends. If you are the spammy type the Carbine with muzzle booster does wonders. Henry if you want a decently fast "sniper" that one shots.
Long Range: Objectively speaking, the Carbine is better. However not by much as the Henry can 2 hit at range.
Ammo avalibility:Carbine. I mean, how many People do you see running around with battle rifles and guns like the MC51? not many.
Conclusion: Neither tops the other from a professional standpoint but in the end, the Henry has just the right Mix of stats to be more user (noob) friendly. It is a low risk, high reward option (relatively speaking). The carbine on the other hand is a high risk, even higher reward option should you know what you are doing.